Drag the Report an Error bookmarklet to your toolbar Drag to toolbar!
Bug #38427 closed:corrected

A Blind Eye to the Truth

 
This bug appeared in a news report published by Huffington Post on Jun 12, 2013 by David Moye. View the original news report.
Bug Type:  Other

“Eyeball Licking Causing Pinkeye in Japan,” screamed the headline on a June 12, 2013 Huffington Post article. Eyeball licking! It was another unbelievable story made in Japan. Citing the Daily Caller, Huff Post reporter, David Moye, noted that  “eye experts are worried that this dangerous fad is gaining popularity with preteens, especially after news reports of elementary school students in Japan who dared to test their ocular boundaries and caused multiple cases of pinkeye, otherwise known as conjunctivitis…”

 Moyes tale made a perfect addition to the Western media’s “annals of weird Japan” with all the factors that go into making such a story, including the fact that it just might be entirely made up. In “Lick This!” a feature story appearing in the August 2013 edition of the Foreign Correspondent’s Club of Japan’s magazine, Number 1 Shimbun,  Tokyo-based writer, Mark Schreiber, lifts the lid on the eyeball licking story to discover there is more (or actually a lot less) to it than meets the eye. Schreiber writes that “it was not especially difficult to at least cast doubts on the sweeping claim that large numbers of Japanese adolescents were suffering from an epidemic of tongue-induced pink eye.” After contacting a couple of Japanese ophthalmological associations, a school clinicians’ organization and other medical professionals, the urban myth-busting author says “none of them had the faintest idea of what I was talking about.” 

While eyeball licking may not really be a trend in Japan, turning a blind eye to the truth may be the trend at the Huff Post and other media outlets. It seems that delivering a tall tale that will catch the reader’s eye sure licks lifting the lid on a story to take a hard look at the facts.

 

Supporting Information:

Related article: "Lick This!" by Mark Schreiber

Related MediaBug report: Falling for a Fake Story...

Response

JT Cassidy has contacted Huffington Post and received the following response.

I contacted the Huff Post using the "suggest a correction" button below the original story.  The article's author, David Moye, got in touch with me nearly write away via email. Here is his response:

"Hi John:
As a point of clarification: Are you questioning the original sources ShanghaiList and Matome.Naver.jp or the original reporting in our piece?
Like you, we had difficulties tracking down the Japanese sources.
Instead of printing the story verbatim as the Daily Caller did, we used the original story as sourced by ShanghaiList -- which they got from a Japanese language publication (links below) --  as a jumping off point to discuss the trend,which has existed since the mid-2000s. 
Here are the links for those stories:
http://shanghaiist.com/2013/06/10/japanese_teens_are_spreading_pink_eye_by_licking_each_others_eyeballs.php
The Japanese version that is the original source is here: http://matome.naver.jp/odai/2137058819724992001
Although we linked to ShanghaiList and Daily Caller, we focused the bulk of the story on interviewing doctors stateside about potential dangers. We also spoke with two people stateside who have done the activity, including HuffPost Weird News staffer Andy Campbell.
We also included a gallery of YouTube videos showing actual eyeball licking, admittedly not from the Japanese students featured in ShanghaiList's story.
We at HuffPost Weird News tend to be skeptical of weird news stories from Japan for the reason cited in the Media Bugs article. 
However, we gave this story more credence since eyeball licking has existed since the mid-2000s (there are lots of YouTube videos showing people doing it), and because we had two sources who discussed it on the record. Also, the eye experts we contacted were well aware of the existing trend as well as the ShanghaiList and Daily Caller stories.
I hope this helps."

Update

The Huffington Post updated its story on August 7, adding:

"That story may be a hoax, according to Mark Schrieber, who writes for The Japan Times.

He said that he contacted three Japanese professional organizations, including two ophthalmological associations, a university professor and an organization of school clinicians to find out about the Japanese eyeball licking outbreak.

"None of them had the faintest idea of what I was talking about," Schrieber wrote inNo. 1 Shimbun, a trade publication for foreign correspondents in Japan. "None knew anything about the rampant spread of disease."

 

Bug History

Aug 03, 2013 11:20 pm Open JT Cassidy
Aug 04, 2013 7:05 pm Open: Responded To JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 3:47 am Closed: Corrected JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 3:50 am Open: Responded To JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 3:55 am Closed: Corrected JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 4:18 am Open: Responded To JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 4:20 am Closed: Corrected JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 4:22 am Open: Responded To JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 4:22 am Closed: Corrected JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 5:37 pm Open: Responded To JT Cassidy
Aug 08, 2013 5:44 pm Closed: Corrected JT Cassidy

Discussion Leave a comment

 

I was hoping the Huff Post would make some note about the dubious origins (as uncovered by Mark Schreiber in "Lick This!") of its references to Japanese school kids but I was really pleased to get any response at all. Huff Post reporter, David Moye, got back to me really quickly with a straightforward explanation that broke down the reporting process on the whole story (which I've copied to the above report).

I've filed more than a few of these bug reports and, with the exception of the New York Times and now the Huffington Post, the response has always been the same: nada. There may be more to this story than meets the eye but the way I see it, Moyes' honest response and transparency about his reporting makes him kind of a rare gem in the truth telling business that is journalism.

Aug 04, 2013 7:23 pm
 

The response above says the author "got in touch with me nearly write away via email." That's "write away" as
in he responded in writing right away.

Aug 04, 2013 10:58 pm
 

The Huffington Post updated this story on August 7, 2013. See the response section above for further details.

Kudos to the Huff Post and David Moye for the informative update. I guess it makes the Huffington Post one in a million.

Aug 08, 2013 4:22 am
 

The Huffington Post has also just published a related story by David Moye that sets the record straight called "Japanese School Eyeball Licking Outbreak At School Reportedly A Hoax."

You can read it here: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/08/07/japanese-eyeball-licking_n_3721920.html?1375974073

Aug 08, 2013 5:44 pm