The Wall Street Journal: Cavalier about corrections?

Last week I wrote about my fruitless quest to alert the Wall Street Journal to a mistake it had made in a book review — misspelling the name of the author the piece mainly focused on.

Yesterday I made one final effort to close this loop; I emailed the book review’s author, Philip Delves Broughton. Broughton responded quickly and courteously, agreed that it was a mistake (one he’d been responsible for), and noted that as a freelance contributor all he could do was notify the book review’s editor.

As of today this mistake, now 11 days old, remains uncorrected. In the face of my persistent and no doubt annoying barrage of emails, phone calls, and blog posts, the Journal newsroom has remained entirely mum.

Now, there are a few ways to read this situation. You could say: Who cares? It’s just a misspelling of somebody’s name.

If it’s your name, of course, you may care a great deal. If you’re the author, you might care not just for vanity, but for the sake of the people who might be Googling your writing or looking your book up to purchase it on Amazon.

In this case, the author, Mac McClelland, happens, right now, to be doing some on-the-ground reporting from the Gulf oil spill for Mother Jones. If you were her, you might want readers to connect the book review with the in-the-news byline.

So another possible response is: The Journal’s editors and reporters are very busy people. They’ve got financial meltdowns to cover. Why are you harassing them with this trivia?

That’s just fine — unless the Journal actually cares whether its readers trust its coverage. If a news outlet can’t be bothered to get an author’s name right, can you count on it to get the financial stories right?

I’m sorry, but none of these responses is adequate. Until and unless we get a more plausible response, the only interpretation that makes sense is a very sad one: that the Wall Street Journal, once one of the world’s great trusted news institutions, lacks a functioning correction process. Or it simply doesn’t care about sweating the details any more.

UPDATE: This post is now linked to from Romenesko, and the very first comment there provides a nice illustration of my argument. Mark Jackson writes, “Really? This is a big deal to you? Column inches. Limited space. Priorities. Possibly the world financial system crashing was a bigger issue? Just sayin’.”

It seems to me that the Journal has every right to say, “We no longer have the resources to fix small errors like misspelled names. You should no longer count on us getting that stuff right.”

Something tells me no editor at the paper is likely to say that. Because when most of us signed on as journalists we signed on for the small stuff too. And readers expect that — and expect some kind of response from the newsroom when they point out an error.

[Crossposted at my personal blog at Wordyard.com]

Report an Error Report an error

Comments

  1. This is great since I don’t need to grab a pot holder or towel to open the lid. According to these sites, the batteries and other accessories you’ll
    need can be purchased inexpensively on auction sites.
    Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) is still interested in receiving
    incident or injury reports that are either directly related to this product
    recall or involve a different hazard with the same product.

  2. Shelby says:

    5. fake ones. Who even knows if it will happen.

  3. zquiet says:

    I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I do not know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already
    ;) Cheers!

  4. Lashonda says:

    Due to the increasing availability of the application of the net along
    with a huge group of individuals marketing things online, it becomes easy for you.
    There are gas powered, electric, and corded chainsaws.

    Modern saw technology offers potential owners two distinctly different paths when it
    comes to what type of technology they want their saw to operate with.

  5. Paige says:

    The stock is propelled by the force and momentum of the saw’s engaged blade and catapulted back at the user at speeds that can reach (or exceed) one-hundred miles per hour. You now have a table saw dust collector that costs you less money. On the other hand there are certain hand made accessories which are comparatively costless.

  6. A safety relief valve is a very important part because it is where the pressure will go out if it exceeds the maximum.
    Will you be moving around, or are you going to stay put.
    The smallest air compressors produced by Campbell Hausfeld are
    pancake style machines whose air tanks are wide, flattened disc shapes.

  7. Fredericka says:

    Today, there are two popular choices in grilling namely gas grills and charcoal grills.
    This article lists the various types of these units based on
    the place where they may be used. Another big difference between a portable grill and a regular one
    is that the portable grill uses a small propane cylinder rather than a conventional five-gallon propane
    tank.

  8. Ben says:

    He stopped offering subsidized oil prices to his own
    people, because Venezuela was making a fortune selling it to the rest
    of the world. There are two ways to go about this,
    firstly, change your diet and secondly use some natural products that
    help adjust your sugar levels without the side effects.

    There is the Neapolitan pizza usually called the pizza Napolitano.

  9. weight loss says:

    Marvelous article! Though I’m more interested in the symmetrical theme you’re using, mind sharing the name?

  10. Hi there, the whole thing iss going perfectly here and ofcourse every
    one is sharing data, that’s actually excellent, keep up writing.

  11. Tilly says:

    If your residence has an outdoor patio then barstools will certainly be perfect to
    be kept there, and even if you have guests over and have less seating arrangements, then
    you can use barstools as they occupy really much less room and are comfortable to
    be utilized. At 10,500 square foot, this shop provides all
    the same first class interior furnitures and medical spas.
    The barstools are available in a range of layouts, forms
    and colours to match your taste.

  12. I put on not need to do too many things to have a cup of coffee.
    Run your regular coffee cycle and allow the mix job completely through your coffee maker.
    We have cut back on getting sodas in our residence since iced herbal tea is better
    and more affordable.

  13. As you may all know eight Ball Pool by Miniclip is the largest and best multiplayer Pool game
    on the internet! It offers you the capacity to play for free from other opponents.
    It really is difficult to get coins when you really don’t have the eight
    Ball greatest tool four.3 this is why you will
    need to have this instrument to show off
    in the multiplayer tournaments and can brag with the eight ball
    ultimate hack 4.three you were in a position to buy all sorts of cues and desk pores and skin.
    With this 8 Ball multiplayer cheat you ready to enter the pool store and buying anything to
    customise your profile to your eyes. With two clicks you
    will have Free Miniclip Credits, Unlimited Free eight Ball Multiplayer
    Pool Details, Totally free eight Ball Multiplayer Awards and previous but not least Free of charge
    8 Ball Pool Multiplayer Accuracy Hack. You
    will nearly often car-win your 8ball game titles. With the 8 Ball Pool Supreme
    Hack four.three, You will no longer have to spend your entire working day attempting to generate all achievements or squander your beneficial income on pool cues,
    tables or boosts! This 8 Ball Multiplayer Hack will save you valuable time by having all what you
    need in a single click on, You will be ready to change quantity
    of cash you desire much. It gives several features that no other equipment will supply.

    What are you waiting around for? Make the most of 8
    Ball Pool Multiplayer!

  14. Hello, its nice post concerning media print, we all know media is a
    great source of facts.

  15. mlm online says:

    Link exchange is nothing else however it is only placing the
    other person’s website link on your page at appropriate place and other person will also do same for you.

  16. Ivy says:

    It’s very simple to find out any matter on web as
    compared to textbooks, as I found this post at this web site.

  17. u dzieci says:

    Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme
    of this blog. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s difficult to get that
    “perfect balance” between superb usability and visual appearance.
    I must say that you’ve done a amazing job with this.
    In addition, the blog loads very quick for me on Opera. Outstanding Blog!

  18. t15.org says:

    Heya i’m for the first time here. I came across this board and I in finding
    It really useful & it helped me out much. I’m hoping to provide one thing back and help others such as you helped
    me.

  19. This voyage will provide an ideal opportunity for both ken photographers and wildlife
    enthusiasts to see and kee a visual record of a once in a lifetime expedition to
    the Southern Ocean. This ‘classic’ style of swinging, featuring much
    more active hips and legs, and a free release of
    the clubhead, can be seen as far back as 1900 and before.
    You really should check out out their Dagger Agent 6.

  20. Hello, just wanted to tell you, I loved this post.
    It was practical. Keep on posting!

  21. Sat-Insta aге Manchester based satellite TV, Aerial аnԀ hօme entertainment specialists.

    TV Aerial & Satellite TV Installaions Ƅy Professionals
    A digital compatible television aerial, combined աith a
    digital television, Freeview BT Vision oor Virgin Media
    set tօp box installation, ѡill ensure yօur home is ready for the digital switchover,
    аnԁ wiill also provide уоu ԝith ɡreat digital television channels,
    ɑnd a range of digital TV interactive services.
    Ԝе сaո supply аnd install a range of Analogue
    TV Aerials, Digital TV Aerials capable оff recriving Freeview, ɑnd DAB Radio aerials.

    Ԝe аlso service & maintain existing sysdtems аnd provide
    a TV aerial repair service.
    Free Estimates аге provided foг alll new TV Aerial installations

  22. I am extremely inspired along with your writing abilities as neatly as with the structure
    in your blog. Is this a paid topic or did you modify it yourself?
    Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a
    great weblog like this one these days..

  23. Sat-Inwta are Manchesfer based satellite TV, Aeroal
    ɑnd home entertainment specialists.
    TV Aerial & Satellite TV Installations Ƅy Professionals
    А digital compatible television aerial,
    combined աith a digital television, Freeview BT Vision ߋr Virgin Media set
    tοp box installation, ѡill ensure yօur home is ready foor tɦe digital switchover, аnd will also provide
    yoս ԝith great digital television channels, aand ɑ range օf digital TV interactive services.
    Ԝе ϲan supply and install а range of Analogue TV Aerials, Digital TV
    Aerials capable οf receiving Freeview,
    ɑnd DAB Radio aerials.
    We also service & maintain existing systems ɑnd provide
    a TV aerial repair service.
    Free Estimates ɑгe provided for ɑll new TV Aerial installations

  24. It is enhanced by sonic boom in a impressive line-up of stretch of land, air and sea
    cars or trucks. No doubt this was what Sony intended by making the claims they did.

    These colors encourage the controller to be seen and
    tracked with the webcam.

  25. Hi there would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re working with? I’m planning to start my own blog soon but I’m having a hard time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something unique. P.S Apologies for being off-topic but I had to ask! Please take a look this: Những kiểu rèm cửa sổ đẹp 2014

  26. Sat-Insta are Manchester based satellite TV, Aerial аnd home entertainment specialists.

    TV Aerial & Satellite TV Installations ƅy Professionals
    A digital compatible television aerial, combined աith a digital
    television, Freeview BT Vision oг Virgin Media set top box installation, աill ensure your home is ready foor tɦe digital switchover, ɑnd will alseo provvide ʏou
    with ցreat digital television channels, аnd a range օf digital TV interactive services.

    Ԝe can supply ɑոd install a range ߋf Analogue
    TV Aerials, Digital TV Aerials capable օf receiving Freeview, aոd DAB Radio aerials.

    We also service & maintain existing systems ɑոd provide a TV aerial repair service.

    Free Estimates аrе provided for ɑll neew TV Aerial installations

  27. Sat-Insta are Mancherster based satellite TV, Aerial аոd hoe entertainment specialists.

    TV Aerial & Satgellite TV Installations ƅy Professionals
    Α digital compatible television aerial, combined աith
    a digital television, Freeview BT Vsion ߋr Virgin Media set top box installation, ԝill ensure
    үouг home iss ready for tthe digital switchover,
    аnd will also proovide үou with great digital television channels,
    аnd a range of digital TV interactive services. Ԝe caո supply and instqll a
    range of Analogue TV Aerials, Digital TV Aerials capable
    oof receiving Freeview, аոd DAB Radiio aerials.
    We alѕߋ service & maintain existing systems annd provide а TV aerial
    repair service.
    Free Estimates аre provided for all new TV Aerial installations

  28. Hello to every single one, it’s genuinely a fastidious for me to pay a visit this site, it contains precious Information.

  29. This required two components to work — a client application
    running on the attacker’s computer and a server application running
    on the victim’s computer. There are many streaming TV services out there that take a long time to load because they are not working on a P2P
    network. In this world, technology changes every now and
    then.

  30. 013 has already delivered an onslaught of marvellous adventure titles.
    Call of Duty Black Ops IIPC, PS3, XBOX 360Now that the story of the Call of Duty:
    Modern Warfare series has come to a close,
    it’s Treyarch’s turn to continue the story of Call of Duty: Black Ops.
    The last step is to distress the costume for a hard effect.

  31. Everyone loves it when folks get together and share opinions.

    Great blog, continue the good work!

  32. guide says:

    This human touch cannot be duplicated by the software programs currently available.
    Learn more about which get paid for taking surveys potentials you ccan gain from
    the a large number of. Typing, answering phone calls and emails, scheduling travel plans, and bookkeeping are a few of the many varied
    tasks a virtual assistant may need to perform.

  33. Cord administration freaks need to ignore that continue remark, utilize a
    modular PSU, custom-made sleeve the PSU, zip association everything, and
    finish by contemplating why that does not qualify as OCD.

    Since you’ll find a great number of features
    to the tower fans it can be important which you understand precisely just what you may be
    seeking . Because he was very young, Roland’s been on a journey to get to the titular Tower, losing
    close friends, reducing wicked, and complying with some really bizarre characters en route.

  34. Latoya says:

    Intrepid users recently discovered January’s PS+ games that have yet to be confirmed
    by Sony, but as the article on Dualshockers states, the site
    confirmed a video in the “Free Games” section of the Playstation Store.
    Later, we soon discovered the diverse advantages of playing on the go
    with the Nintendo DS, 3DS, Play – Station Portable and the Play – Station Vita.

    I’ve always thought, as well as some of my
    friends, that a paid PSN might have the features necessary to compete with
    Xbox Live and overtake it.

  35. It is enhanced by sonic boom in a impressive line-up of stretch of land,
    air and sea cars or trucks. This disk image can then be burned onto a blank CD or
    DVD in your burner drive. I’ve always thought, as well as some of my friends, that a paid PSN might have the features necessary to compete with Xbox Live and
    overtake it.

  36. Just wish to say your article is as astounding. The clearness in your post is just excellent and i could assume you’re an expert on
    this subject. Fine with your permission allow
    me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post.
    Thanks a million and please carry on the gratifying work.

  37. alexa.com says:

    Tremendous issues here. I’m very satisfied to see your post.
    Thanks a lot and I’m having a look forward to touch you.
    Will you kindly drop me a mail?

  38. leczenie says:

    This post presents clear idea for the new
    people of blogging, that genuinely how to do blogging.

  39. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    The text in your content seem to be running off
    the screen in Internet explorer. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to
    do with browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The design and style look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon.
    Many thanks

  40. Sat-Insta are Manchester based satellite TV, Aerial аnd home entertainment specialists.

    TV Aerial & Satellite TV Intallations Ьy Professionzls
    Α digital compatible television aerial,
    combined ԝith a digital television, Freeview BT Vision ߋr Virgin Media set tοp box installation, աill ensure үour home iѕ ready fοr the
    digital switchover, and will also provide yօu wuth great digital television
    channels, аnd a range ߋf digital TV interactiive services.

    Ԝe can supply ɑnd install ɑ range օf Analogue TV Aerials, Digital TV Aerials capable оf receiving Freeview, аnԀ DAB
    Radio aerials.
    Ԝe also service & maintain existing systems ɑnd provide a
    TV aerial repair service.
    Freee Estimates ɑre provided for all ոew TV Aefial installations

  41. Unquestionably believe that which you stated.

    Your favorite reason seemed to be on the internet the easiest thing to be
    aware of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people think about
    worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed
    to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people
    can take a signal. Will probably be back to get more.
    Thanks

  42. Randi says:

    Naturally, satellite radios with a number of recreations channels are actually
    an innovation that is actually usually pursued. On-line you are going to discover numerous
    different options in a singular valuable resource. Make certain and keep your notification cool as well as informal,
    just like a close friend giving yet another good friend an insider recommendation.

  43. After a short period of time, the animals tend to appear and the hunt is on. Bow hunters spend hours practicing to get
    just the right shot. Tricia Hamill love hunting, and He know you do too, so he wanted to put advice for how
    to choose best hunting Rifle Scopes.

  44. I’d like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this site.
    I am hoping to see the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future as well.

    In truth, your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own, personal website now ;)

  45. psn karte says:

    I every time spent my half an hour to read this webpage’s
    articles all the time along with a mug of coffee.

  46. Awesome issues here. I’m very glad to see your article. Thanks so much and I am having a look forward to contact you.

    Will you please drop me a e-mail?

  47. Krystyna says:

    However, nothing can be compared to an Internet-based outdoor network which allows users to share
    all of their exciting hunting stories on the web for others to read and discuss.

    The most obvious thing that a hunter can do is to have good boots.
    So lets look at this first you need to speak with one of the hunting
    networks to figure out what your airtime costs will be, then you have
    to look at production cost: editing, cameramen, traveling, hunts etc.

  48. A radial division viewed needs far less room to operate efficiently when compared
    with a table saw. Also, there are several sorts of miter
    saw available. You may also stash it rapidly when you are actually not using this,
    due to its little measurements as well as light-weight.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] of paper somewhere that guaranteed such a thing. (DL) REGARDS to the Wall Street Journal, which is apparently busy doing whatever else it is doing to issue simple corrections to name misspellings in book reviews. Or to respond to someone pointing [...]

  2. [...] isn’t the first time we’ve encountered a void when trying to reach the Journal about an error report. And while the previous instance involved a [...]

  3. [...] isn’t the first time we’ve encountered a void when trying to reach the Journal about an error report. And while the previous instance involved a [...]

  4. [...] We agree. The question is, does the Wall Street Journal? We may not get an answer to that; thus far the Journal has been unresponsive to inquiries about Yoo’s piece, and its newsroom has proven inaccessible on such matters in prior cases. [...]

  5. [...] We agree. The question is, does the Wall Street Journal? We may not get an answer to that; thus far the Journal has been unresponsive to inquiries about Yoo’s piece, and its newsroom has proven inaccessible on such matters in prior cases. [...]

Speak Your Mind

*